Two Housewives and an Axe: The Silicon Prairie Murder (9 photos)
Crimes of passion happen all over the world, but unfortunately, they don't always end in minor scuffles or disturbing the peace. Every year, tens of thousands of people lose their lives to jealousy. Sometimes, in the heat of the moment, the jealous partners themselves end up suffering. While most of these stories become nameless statistics, the most brutal and unusual cases end up inspiring movies and TV shows. That was precisely what happened on June 13, 1980, in the small Texas town of Wylie.
The Secret Affair Begins
Candy Wheeler and Pat Montgomery were widely seen as a devoted, loving couple. They met in their youth and soon decided to tie the knot. After getting married, Pat and Candy settled in a northeast suburb of Dallas known as the Silicon Prairie. The couple went on to have two children, first a daughter named Jenni and later a son named Ian.
Candy and Pat Montgomery
They seemed like any ordinary middle-class American family. Pat worked as an engineer while Candy was a secretary. Everything was going smoothly until the summer of 1978, when Candy met Allan Gore at a church volleyball game. Allan was the husband of her close friend, Betty. He was hardly a dreamboat: slightly overweight, balding, wearing thick glasses and baggy clothes, Allan was a textbook average family man.
Allan Gore
Yet Candy was captivated by Allan's charm and their shared interests. They ended up talking long after the game, completely forgetting about their families. That chance encounter sparked a secret romance that was in full swing by late 1978. They met at cheap motels out of town. To keep suspicious expenses off their bank statements, the lovers split the costs of rooms, gas, and food right down the middle.
Betty and Allan Gore with their children shortly before the tragedy
Meanwhile, Allan's wife Betty desperately wanted a second child. Her constant talk about starting a family weighed heavily on Allan's conscience, and he decided to call off the affair. After a frank discussion, the lovers parted ways amicably without anger or resentment. They agreed to remain friends and keep their secret safe. Soon after, Betty gave birth, and for a while, Allan put Candy out of his mind.
A Relapse in Passion
But domestic bliss didn't last long. With Betty preoccupied with the new baby, Allan began to feel lonely. One day, he picked up the phone and dialed Candy's number, reigniting their romance. Still, after every secret rendezvous, Allan was consumed by guilt—he truly loved his wife and kids. After discussing his conflicted feelings several times with Candy, she finally took the initiative and called an end to the affair once and for all.
A scene from the series "Candy"
That might have been the end of it, just like thousands of other mundane affairs. But this story was about to take a gruesome turn. On June 13, 1980, Candy Montgomery dropped by her friend Betty's house to chat. During their conversation, Betty out of nowhere asked if Candy was having an affair with her husband. Candy confessed, but insisted it had been over for a long time and that she was deeply sorry.
Betty stood up without a word and left the room. She returned a couple of minutes later holding an axe. No one knows for sure what was going through her mind—she may have just wanted to scare her rival. But Candy didn't wait to find out. She grabbed the weapon from Betty's hands and shoved her into an open utility closet.
A scene from the series "Love & Death"
Candy later claimed her mind went blank and she had no memory of what happened next. Forensic examiners later counted 41 axe wounds on Betty Gore's body. The victim's head suffered the worst of the attack, left disfigured save for a single intact eye. Once the frenzy subsided, the killer realized what she had done. In a state of shock, she walked home without attempting to cover her tracks or even closing the front door behind her.
A Bizarre Claim of Self-Defense
Allan was away on a business trip in another state at the time. After calling home several times with no answer, he grew worried and asked a neighbor to drop by and check on his wife. The neighbor obliged and was the first to discover the horrific scene. Betty's mutilated body lay in a pool of drying blood. In the next room, a hungry baby was crying uncontrollably.
The crime scene
The neighbor immediately broke the devastating news to Allan and called the police, taking in the helpless infant. Candy quickly became the primary suspect. She had been spotted near the Gore home and was known to be the last person to see Betty alive. Within hours, police uncovered the affair, and Candy was taken into custody.
Candy hired a defense attorney who immediately began building a case for self-defense, arguing the death was a tragic accident. However, prosecutors and the public found it hard to believe that striking someone 41 times with an axe qualified as self-defense. Leaving an infant to potentially starve was another damning factor stacked against her.
Not Guilty!
Things were looking grim for Candy, who faced the real possibility of life in prison. But everything changed after a series of sessions with a hypnotist. Under hypnosis, Candy revealed that she completely lost control of herself when Betty approached her with the axe and shushed her. Betty may have been trying to quiet her down, but to Candy, the "shh" sound triggered childhood trauma from her strict, abusive mother, who used to hiss at her when angry. Overcome by blind terror, Candy seized the axe and flew into a frenzy.
A newspaper article covering the Montgomery trial
The testimony obtained under hypnosis proved decisive—as did the fact that Betty had brought the axe into the room in the first place. The jury acquitted Montgomery, and she walked free. The scandal tore her family apart; following her divorce, Candy relocated and changed her name. She later trained as a family therapist and set up a practice in Georgia, specializing—ironically enough—in marriage counseling.
The Shakespearean drama in the Silicon Prairie sent shockwaves across America. People fiercely debated both the motives behind the murder and Candy's acquittal. Many felt that memories retrieved under hypnosis were far too shaky a foundation to let a killer go unpunished.
Candy Montgomery today
Public fascination with the case endures to this day. It inspired the 2022 Hulu miniseries "Candy," starring Jessica Biel and Melanie Lynskey as Candy and Betty. In 2023, another television adaptation, "Love & Death," hit the screens, starring Elizabeth Olsen and Lily Rabe.
While Candy was declared innocent, another woman sharing her surname—Lisa Montgomery—was executed in 2021 for the brutal murder of a pregnant woman inside her own home.


















